Grade 4 Listening and Speaking: Debate Solar Panels and Present an Energy-Saving Plan [Lesson 8 – Energy for Our Planet]

Term 3 | Level 3 | Phonics focus: the roots therm, hydro, bio and eco, and ei after c

Lesson 8 – Energy for Our Planet  |  Lessons – Index

Lessons

This page has the two listening and speaking lessons of Lesson 8, Energy for Our Planet: Lessons 8.5 and 8.6. The Lesson 8 page has the Lesson 8 overview, the Lesson 8 review and the PDF download.

Select a lesson to go straight to it. Each lesson ends with a link back to the top of the page.

Lesson 8.5: Debate: Should Our School Use Solar Panels?

Oral | About 20 minutes



Term 3 | Level 3

Goal

“I can take part in a debate by giving reasons and evidence, listening to the other side and answering it politely.”

Words to know

debate, argument, for, against, evidence, rebuttal


Wonder

Think about this question before you start. Say your ideas. You will come back to it at the end of the lesson.

Is it possible to disagree with someone and still be kind?


Let’s Learn

In a debate, two sides discuss a question. One side argues for it, and the other argues against it. Each speaker gives reasons and evidence, listens carefully to the other side, and then answers their points. Answering the other side is called a rebuttal. A good debater stays polite, even when they disagree.

A school building with rows of blue solar panels on its red roof, on a sunny day. Should our school use solar panels?For (Yes)• They make electricity without smoke.• The school would pay less for electricity overtime.• Pupils could learn how they work.Against (No)• They cost a lot of money to buy and fit.• They make no electricity at night.• The money could buy books or sports kit now. Useful sentence starters for a debateGive your viewI believe that… because…Add evidenceFor example… / This shows that…Answer the other sideSome people say…, but…Agree politelyI agree with … that…, however…Sum upSo, overall, I think…

See How It’s Done

Zara at a bookshelf thinks through the steps for Debate: Should Our School Use Solar Panels.

Now Try It

1. Choose one argument for solar panels. Add your own evidence or example. ______________________________

2. Answer this point politely: Solar panels cost too much.

__________________________________________________________________


Time To Practise

Name: ______________________

1. Choose your side.

Decide whether you are for or against solar panels at your school. ______________

2. Plan three reasons.

1. __________________________________________________________

2. __________________________________________________________

3. __________________________________________________________

3. Predict and prepare.

Write one point the other side might make, and how you would answer it.

They might say: __________________________________________________

I would answer: __________________________________________________

4. Hold the debate.

Debate with an adult or a group. Each speaker has one minute to give their view, then one minute to answer the other side. Use the sentence starters.

An adult listens and ticks each one they hear.

☐ a clear view    ☐ reasons with evidence    ☐ listened without interrupting    ☐ answered the other side politely    ☐ summed up

5. Reflect.

Did the other side change your mind about anything? Write one sentence.

__________________________________________________________________


Reflect

Think about these questions. Talk about them with someone at home or at school.

1. Go back to the Wonder question: “Is it possible to disagree with someone and still be kind?” What do you think now?

2. I was open-minded today when I ______________________________.

Being open-minded means listening to other ideas and other ways of doing things. For example: I was open-minded today when I listened carefully to a view I disagreed with.

Take action: Hold a family debate on another energy question, such as whether to walk to school more often.


Next Steps

If this was easy, try: Write a short speech for the side you did not choose. Use the best arguments you heard.

If this was hard, go back to: Let’s Learn. Read the arguments for and against aloud. Choose one from each side and say why it is strong.


Notes for Parents and Teachers

Show notes for parents and teachers

These notes cover this lesson only. How every lesson runs is explained in How to Use This Material.

Let’s Learn

Read Let’s Learn aloud together. Talk about the arguments on both sides.

Time To Practise

  • Task 4: Tick each one you hear.

Answer Key

Reveal Answers

Now Try It

1. Sample answer: Pupils could learn how they work. For example, a screen in the hall could show how much electricity the panels make each day.   2. Sample answer: That is true, but the school would pay less for electricity every year, so over time the panels would pay for themselves.

1 to 3. Answers will vary. Look for: three clear reasons and a sensible answer to the other side.

4. Look for: four or more ticks.

5. Answers will vary.

Reflect

2. Any real moment from the lesson that shows the learner was open-minded. Examples: “I was open-minded today when I listened carefully to a view I disagreed with.” “I was open-minded today when I answered politely with a reason.”


Back to top

Lesson 8.6: Present an Energy-Saving Plan

Oral | About 20 minutes

Term 3 | Level 3

Goal

“I can present a clear plan with actions, reasons and a visual, speaking clearly to my audience.”

Words to know

plan, action, presentation, audience, visual, persuade


Wonder

Think about this question before you start. Say your ideas. You will come back to it at the end of the lesson.

What is one thing your family could do this week to save energy?


Let’s Learn

A plan says what will be done, who will do it, when, and how you will know it worked. When you present a plan, you explain each action and give a reason for it, so your audience wants to join in.

Tomás points to the class energy plan on the whiteboard while four classmates listen. ActionWhoWhenHow we will checkLights off when we leaveEnergy monitorEvery breakTick chart by the doorScreens off at lunchTeacherEvery lunchtimeMonitor checksClose doors in winterEveryoneAll daySign on each door

A good presentation of a plan:

  • starts with the problem: Our school wastes energy every day.
  • explains each action with a reason
  • uses a visual, such as a table or poster
  • speaks clearly, looks at the audience and pauses between points
  • ends by asking the audience to help: Will you be our first energy monitors?

See How It’s Done

Ben at a bookshelf thinks through the steps for Present an Energy-Saving Plan.

Now Try It

1. Why does a plan need a Who column? ______________________________

2. Write an ending that asks the audience to help. ______________________________


Time To Practise

Name: ______________________

1. Choose a place.

Choose your home, your classroom or a club. ______________

2. Make your plan.

ActionWhoWhenHow we will check
    
    
    

3. Add reasons.

Write a reason for each action.

1. ______________________________   2. ______________________________   3. ______________________________

4. Present it.

Present your plan to your family or class for one to two minutes, using your table as a visual.

An adult listens and ticks each one they hear or see.

☐ started with the problem    ☐ a reason for each action    ☐ pointed to the visual    ☐ clear voice and eye contact    ☐ asked the audience to help


Reflect

Think about these questions. Talk about them with someone at home or at school.

1. Go back to the Wonder question: “What is one thing your family could do this week to save energy?” What do you think now?

2. I was caring today when I ______________________________.

Being caring means being kind and helping others. For example: I was caring today when I made a plan that helps the people around me and the planet.

Take action: Put your plan into action at home for one week, then report back on what changed.


Next Steps

If this was easy, try: Add a chart to your plan that shows how you will record your progress over four weeks.

If this was hard, go back to: Let’s Learn. Read the model plan one row at a time and say each action with its reason.


Notes for Parents and Teachers

Show notes for parents and teachers

These notes cover this lesson only. How every lesson runs is explained in How to Use This Material.

Let’s Learn

Read Let’s Learn aloud together. Look at the model plan together.

Time To Practise

  • Task 4: Tick each one you hear or see.

Answer Key

Reveal Answers

Now Try It

1. So everyone knows whose job it is, and the action does not get forgotten.   2. Sample answer: Please help us by switching off one thing today.

1 to 3. Answers will vary. Look for: three clear actions, each with a person, a time, a way to check and a reason.

4. Look for: four or more ticks.

Reflect

2. Any real moment from the lesson that shows the learner was caring. Examples: “I was caring today when I made a plan that helps the people around me and the planet.” “I was caring today when I asked others to join in.”


Back to top


For Teachers: IB Details

Show IB and curriculum details

IB theme: Sharing the planet. This theme is about the rights and responsibilities we have as we share the planet’s resources with other people and other living things.

Central idea: People get energy from different sources, and the choices we make about energy affect the planet and everyone who shares it.

LessonTitleStrandKey concept
8.5Debate: Should Our School Use Solar Panels?Listening and speakingPerspective
8.6Present an Energy-Saving PlanSpeakingResponsibility

Each lesson also matches the national curriculum for England (Year 4) and the US Common Core (Grade 4). The Grade 4 Curriculum Map lists the full standards for every lesson.

▲ Collapse IB details


← Back to Lesson 8 – Energy for Our Planet  |  Lessons – Index


© 2026 Firefly Ed. All rights reserved. This page may be printed for personal, home and classroom use. It may not be sold, shared online or reproduced for commercial use without written permission. edfirefly.com

Discover more from Firefly Ed

Subscribe now to get access to the full archive, PDF printable lessons and new content updates. Don’t miss out on new assets.

Comments

Share your thoughts or ask something..

Check also

View Archive [ -> ]